Spirited. Fun. Free. Sign Up Now. You'll love it!

Meet the Team! Click on Photo

We Love Propay - It's Tripled Our Business

  • Propay_2

    Propay - Makes it easy and affordable for small businesses
    to accept credit cards.

TERMS OF USE

© Nancy Mills. All rights reserved. 2005-2020

« Envisioning a Bright Outcome | Main | A Chock-Full Calendar »

February 03, 2011

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

mingmei yip

Mino, I completely agree with you about childhood memories - my next blog will tell how my mother raised me.

Shandel, Of course I'm sure that Chua loves her children, that's why I think the strictness is more a publicity gimmick.

Thanks!

Mino

Maybe children do better with Tiger Moms and maybe they are affectionate with their children......what I worry about is their kid's childhood memories. My most playful parts of adulthood are related to my free spirited childhood. Play dates, jumping in mud puddles, rolling in tall grass, climbing trees, eating too many cherries, and so much more. I would not want to trade all that in for 3 hour piano classes and an awesome report cards.

mingmei yip

Thanks Aayla and Annie!

Annie, my next blog will be about how my tiger mother taught me in a completely different way from Chua's.

Shandel

I need to read this book-it sounds very interesting. From what I understand, though, Chua is NOT telling people HOW to raise their children, she is explaining the way that SHE did so. And I do not get the sense from interviews and reviews that she did not love her children, or show that she didn't. I think that Tiger Mother has been a success and such a media draw, because parents are very concerned with making sure their kids do not lack self-esteem or get bruised egos. As well as being afraid that they are not parenting "correctly". To hear about such a strict household and a mother being so blunt about it can be a shock.

Sherri Rosen

I was with a man for 2 l/2 years who grew up in a Thai family with a mother who was what you call "Loufu Na"-tiger woman. She and many in her family were doctors, but from this man shared with me, there was no love nor kindness coming from this woman when he was growing up. She wasn't there physically nor emotionally there for him. He is what he calls a "dutiful son", but there is no joy or love that is within their relationship.

He is now studying to become a doctor. A high price has been paid. Is it worth it? You be the judge.

Annie

Thanks Mingmei! As a mother and teacher, I have learned that the worst thing a parent or teacher can do is to assume that one style of parenting or teaching will work the same for every child.

Aayla Avalon

I find all your posts so interesting as they are a window into a life and culture so different from mine.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Your Information

(Name is required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)

Come on! Follow Spirited Woman on

WHY DO YOU FEEL YOU ARE A SPIRITED WOMAN?

FIND OUT HOW TO POST ON A BLOG

Spirited Woman is really growing!